normative

Cruel to Punish People for Uncontrollable Endowments

Drawing on Thomas Nagel and Burke, if something lies outside your control—your natural endowment for academic ability, whether from genes or environment—then it is cruel to base your life outcomes on it; people in the bottom of the distribution can end up on disability, addicted to Oxycontin in a Rust Belt city, while equally uncontrolled luck lands others in good jobs, so we should not let those outcomes be too negative.

normativepending

Speaker

Fredrik deBoer

Evidence Quote

“If we believe that a great deal of the determination of our outcomes is out of the hands of the individual, then it would seem to me to suggest that we should not let those outcomes be too negative.”

Source

Fredrik deBoer on the Cult of Smart— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...