Example: A workman on a roof sees a loose brick, hates someone on the ground, intentionally throws it and kills them. Hume disapproves because it makes us feel bad for the victim; Kant disapproves because the workman intended to do ill, focusing on intention rather than outcome

factualpending

Speaker

Unidentified Speaker — Kant's Moral Philosophy [d-vcItYxM9U]

Evidence Quote

“imagine a workman working on the roof of a building he's standing up there and he notices a loose brick he sees somebody on the ground says i don't like that guy i've always hated that guy he throws the brick down and kills him now hume would say we don't like that because it makes us feel bad for the poor guy that got hit in the head with a brick kant would say the reason we disapprove of that behavior is because he intended to do ill to someone it's the intention that he had”

Source

Kant's Moral Philosophy— Michael Sugrue
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:26:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...