The traditional criticism that value investors rely on multiple expansion is valid; research by O'Shaughnessy shows that value portfolios generate returns because markets expect value companies to perform worse than they actually do, resulting in multiple expansion as negative expectations are disappointed; to address this, investors can construct portfolios that return satisfactory results without relying on multiple expansion by focusing on reinvestment returns and shareholder yields.

factualpending

Speaker

Tobias Carlisle

Evidence Quote

“there's some good analysis done by o shoresy where they... everybody expects these businesses to do worse than they actually end up doing because that's that's why they're cheap and so your Returns come from... they do have this multiple expansion [15:03]”

Source

Value Had One of Its Worst Periods in History | What Data Tells Us Comes Next— Excess Returns
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:08:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...