Alvin Plantinga, in response to those who claim they do not believe in material bodies or God, responds 'What's wrong with you?'—implying that failure to have these fundamental beliefs indicates malfunction of belief-forming mechanisms, not rational disagreement, and in his Gifford Lectures, Plantinga extends this response to lack of belief in God, treating disbelief as a symptom of dysfunctional belief formation.

factualpending

Speaker

Lecture Instructor

Evidence Quote

“if somebody says to planning uh well I I just don't believe in the existence of material bodies his responses what's wrong with you”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:19:49 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...