definition

Maximizing Rationality Is the Rationality of Animals

Aquinas identifies incentive-driven rationality (do more when paid more, less when taxed more) as the kind of rationality humans share with animals because it runs off pleasures and pains; on this Hobbesian view the only difference between human and animal is that we are cleverer at the calculations, but Aquinas and the ancients posit a higher human rationality that lets us step back from impulses to ask what is good, true, and beautiful and to order our lives around chosen finite goods.

definitionpending

Speaker

Mary Hirschfeld

Evidence Quote

“if that's what it is, the only thing that distinguishes a human from an animal is that we are a little bit cleverer about how to do these calculations. Um, so, that goes back to Hobbes... But, for Aquinas, for Aristotle, or really any of the ancients, there's a higher human rationality”

Source

Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:22 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...