causal

Boston's first-choice-maximizing system was unsafe

Boston's old system tried to give as many families as possible their first choice, using priorities (siblings, proximity, lottery) as tie-breakers when oversubscribed; this made it unsafe to list your true first choice because failing to get it could leave your second choice filled with first-choice applicants—even if you held priority there—so the apparent high rate of families getting 'first choices' masked strategic misreporting.

causalpending

Speaker

Alvin Roth

Evidence Quote

“it looked to them as if a lot of people were getting their first choices. But in fact, people were adjusting what they claimed was their first choice.”

Source

Alvin Roth on Matching Markets— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...