causal

Liberal State, Not Strong State, Is the Right Variable

The relevant variable for tolerance is not raw state strength but commitment to liberal values: a state with sufficient coercive power relative to a minority (like Tokugawa Japan, which sealed off the country to suppress Christianity despite controlling only part of its territory) can thoroughly persecute, while very weak states (the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth) get captured by nobles and privatized, producing feudal arrangements hostile to both markets and freedom—so liberalism requires a state strong enough but committed to liberal values.

causalpending

Speaker

Noel Johnson and Mark Koyama

Evidence Quote

“very weak states... are too easily captured by a few nobles or vested interests. So the state, in some sense, becomes privatized”

Source

Noel Johnson and Mark Koyama— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:52:44 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...