factual
More Data Lengthens Referee Concern Lists
Although adding a confirming dataset statistically strengthens an argument, for many narrow-minded referees additional datasets merely lengthen their list of concerns, leading to rejection—an inversion of how cumulative evidence ought to be evaluated.
factualpending
Speaker
Omer MoavEvidence Quote
“for many referees, that just makes their list of concerns longer. Well, with a longer list of concerns: of course we reject the paper.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:27:25 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...