Smith's commutative justice consists in abstaining from what is another's—not harming a person's person, property, and promises-due (contract), and (in some passages) reputation. Significantly, Smith calls only this 'justice' (later qualifying it 'commutative' after Grotius and the schoolmen) and never calls beneficence or distribution 'distributive justice,' implying he wants 'justice' to mean only commutative justice—a fact revealing his political sensibilities.
factualpending
Speaker
Dan KleinEvidence Quote
“he never calls beneficence and those things distributive justice ... he's saying when we speak of justice ... there's just commutative justice don't call these other things justice basically”
Source
Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/2009— EconTalkCreated: 6/16/2026, 2:17:22 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...