Defining depression as a checklist of symptoms produces absurdities such as the recently bereaved scoring as clinically depressed, which led the DSM to carve out a 'bereavement exception'; researchers then showed bereavement is not meaningfully different from divorce or job loss, and rather than broaden the exception the DSM revision proposed removing it entirely so that all such suffering counts as disease regardless of cause.

factualpending

Speaker

Gary Greenberg

Evidence Quote

“they decided to do was to remove the bereavement exceptions so all depression... you're depressed it doesn't matter why”

Source

Gary Greenberg on Depression, Addiction, and the Brain 09/27/2010— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:00:28 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...