normative
Showing what is good differs from giving advice
Conveying why something is good or beautiful (e.g., loving Ferrante's novels) is legitimate and helps people aspire, but it is fundamentally different from giving advice; one cannot productively advise strangers because good advice requires knowing the person well, not merely being asked.
normativepending
Speaker
Agnes CallardEvidence Quote
“something I can do for them is just explain why something is good or beautiful in such a way that it might hopefully resonate with them and they'll be inspired to pursue it. That's absolutely a thing I can do”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:54 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...