factual

Neptune-vs-Vulcan parable on systematic vs new physics

The history of Uranus/Neptune versus Mercury/Vulcan shows that an identical-looking orbital discrepancy can resolve either as a new object (Neptune, a 'systematic error') or as wrong physics (general relativity explaining Mercury's precession, the 'new physics'), so intuition cannot reliably tell in advance which kind of resolution an anomaly like the Hubble tension will have.

factualpending

Speaker

Adam Riess

Evidence Quote

“Uranus was not traveling as it ought to have been... which turned out to be Neptune... In the case of Mercury... they had the wrong physics, the wrong theory of gravity”

Source

118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:08:48 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...