causal

Freezing notation trades flexibility for satisfying form

The original version of Shaker Loops used finger cues from the conductor, which Adams could realize satisfyingly but other conductors made strangely out of focus; in the later version he froze everything into traditional notation, losing flexibility but gaining a very satisfying fixed form.

causalpending

Speaker

John Adams

Evidence Quote

“So in the later version of it, I froze everything into more traditional notation. That flexibility is no longer there, but on the other hand, the form of the piece is very satisfying.”

Source

John Adams— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:25:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...