What this covers
John Adams speaks with Tyler Cowen about the philosophical and practical foundations of his compositional work. The conversation moves from Adams's early struggles with artistic identity—notably a youthful rebuke of Leonard Bernstein for not composing "proper" atonal music, only to receive the corrective that an artist must do who they are—through his evolving critique of mid-20th-century serialism and 12-tone music as having hollowed music into a laboratory exercise divorced from Music as Communication. Adams describes his own practice: composing what he wants and then seeking commissions, drawing equally from childhood musical theater and the classical canon, and refusing to brand himself through repetition.
The discussion ranges across the nature of performance and notation. Adams argues that a score functions as a Score as Recipe—constantly reborn across different conductors and ensembles—rather than a fixed artifact like a pop recording. He reflects on his operas, from the set pieces of earlier works to the cinematic quicksilver of Antony and Cleopatra, modeled on Claude Debussy rather than operatic tradition. Adams also addresses the paradoxes of contemporary classical music: why Philip Glass draws packed houses while the work of composers like Pierre Boulez remains austere; how composers from Schoenberg onward made audiences permanently wary of new work; and why Scarcity Confers Value in an age of streaming. Personal touchstones emerge—Miles Davis, Ella Fitzgerald, Bob Dylan—alongside Artistic Authenticity and the shadow cast by predecessors, what Harold Bloom termed the Anxiety of Influence.
Adams argues that a composer must reject the prescriptive demands of avant-garde serialism and write music as an act of communication rooted in personal authenticity, drawing equally from popular and classical traditions, and that a written score is a living recipe reborn in each performance rather than a fixed object.
- Mid-20th-century serial/12-tone music alienated audiences by becoming a laboratory rather than communication
- Authenticity ('do who you are') matters more than following the supposedly proper way to make art
- A score is a recipe that changes with every performance, unlike a fixed pop recording
Music succeeds by reaching people and communicating directly rather than becoming inaccessible laboratory experiments.
- Adams finds most setting of the English language in the classical tradition rather pretentious and stiff; his models for treating English are great popular artists like Ella Fitzgerald, Stevie Wonder, Joni Mitchell, and Bob Dylan rather than classical composers like Britten or even Handel.
“I find most setting of the English language in the classical tradition rather a little bit pretentious and a little bit stiff.”
- Boulez's work, exemplified by pieces pushing complexity, density, and fracturing of language to the farthest extreme, represents a period when contemporary music became like a laboratory rather than seeing music as essentially an act of communication; Adams finds the Second Piano Sonata an utterly unpleasant listening experience despite its astonishing difficulty.
“It became like a laboratory rather than seeing music as essentially an act of communication.”
- In the early 20th century many brilliant composers (Schoenberg, Varèse, later John Cage) began writing essentially inaccessible, dissonant, rationally conceived music that deconstructed musical language; this made audiences permanently wary of anything new, so that to this day uninitiated listeners expect a living composer's piece to be an unpleasant experience.
“The bad part of it was that it made audiences very wary of anything that was new. Even to this day, I’m still suffering from that”
- Most film scoring is uninspired because film composers market themselves and simply give directors what they want, and even great directors like Spielberg often have sentimental, tacky musical taste; consequently the best film-score music comes from France or Italy, and many films now use a music consultant assembling pop sources rather than a composer.
“I think that film composers market themselves and basically give directors what they want. And a lot of the taste that even the greatest directors — people like Steven Spielberg — have is just very sentimental and, to me, rather tacky”
An artist must do who they are rather than follow supposedly proper ways or what others prescribe.
- Adams does not follow prescribed requests; he composes whatever he wants (a concerto, opera, string quartet, even a show with pop songs) on his own terms and then looks around for someone to commission it, rather than letting a commission dictate the work.
“if there is a prescribed request, I simply don’t accept it. If I want to do something... I do that, and then I look around for somebody to commission it.”
- Faced with a crisis over why he should surrender the influence great music can have to pop artists by being required to write serial or 12-tone music as a contemporary composer, Adams walked away from the serialist orthodoxy he was surrounded by in college, enduring heavy criticism from major critics who insisted contemporary music had to be difficult and rigorous.
“Why should I surrender the influence that great music can have to a pop artist and have to go and write serial or 12-tone music because that’s what’s required of a contemporary composer?”
- When the young, obnoxious Adams wrote scolding Bernstein for not writing proper atonal or serial music, Bernstein replied 'I have to do what I have to do. This is me,' a lesson Adams later understood as the truth that an artist must do who they are rather than pretend to be someone else or follow the supposedly proper way to make art.
“He said, “I have to do what I have to do. This is me.” That was a really important thing for me to hear.”
Composers must personally control every dimension of their work from conception through final realization.
- Unlike architects who can farm out electrical, plumbing, and concrete work to others, composers must do everything themselves; in this opera Adams personally wrote the libretto, vocal writing, sketching, instrumentation, and even the computer setting of the full score over roughly four years.
“You’re lucky you can farm out the electrical and the plumbing and the concrete to someone else, but we composers, we have to do everything.”
- Adams deliberately makes every piece very different from its predecessor because he never wants to brand himself by producing the same predictable piece, a trap many artists fall into especially once successful.
“the one thing I never want to do is brand myself, produce the same predictable piece. A lot of artists fall into that, especially if they’re successful.”
- Adams does not write for films because effective film composing requires being ready to drop everything and focus without sleep for three or four days, which is incompatible with his full life of commissions and conducting; moreover directors frequently change scenes after he tailors music to them, making the work frustrating.
“in order to be an effective film composer, you have to be ready to drop everything you’re doing and just focus without sleep for three or four days on a project.”
- Charles Ives's compositions are not fully satisfying largely because Ives almost never heard them performed; composing requires hearing your work to learn what does and doesn't work, and Ives, born in 1870s Connecticut into a raw country not ready for an experimental classical composer, was a hermit insurance executive born before his time.
“I think a lot of that has to do with the fact that Ives never heard these pieces, or hardly ever heard them. When you’re composing, you have to hear something and then realize, “Oh, that works and that doesn’t.””
Opera works best when it dramatizes both grand historical forces and intensely intimate human relationships simultaneously.
- Antony and Cleopatra works as an opera because it simultaneously depicts world politics (the rise of one civilization and decline of another) and intensely intimate interpersonal relationships of figures caught up in that maelstrom, and the operatic form emphasizes the interpersonal dimension.
“it’s about world politics. It’s the rise of one civilization and the decline of another. But it’s also very intimate because it’s about people who are caught up in the maelstrom and have very, very powerful intimacy”
- Unlike his earlier operas built around set pieces, choruses, arias, and soliloquies, Adams designed Antony and Cleopatra as a 'musical drama' with quicksilver, fast-moving character interaction more like a Preston Sturges 1930s film, for which his closest operatic model was Debussy's treatment of Pelléas et Mélisande, which kept the play whole and simply musicalized the text.
“in this case, in Antony and Cleopatra, I really wanted to make what I call a musical drama, and the interaction between the characters — it’s quicksilver. It’s really fast.”
- Adams was drawn to Antony and Cleopatra because they were older people who had each lived full lives and had children by others; he modeled their relationship on his own life and people he knew who had difficult relationships but ultimately found love, comparing it to Albee's Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf.
“what drew me to these two characters, Antony and Cleopatra, was the fact that they were older people. One could say they’d been there, done that.”
Musical theater, not classical tradition, is the foundation of Adams's theatrical and operatic sensibility.
- Despite being a 'classical composer,' the musical theater Adams absorbed in childhood (Rodgers and Hammerstein, Cole Porter, having performed in South Pacific) is the deepest part of his identity as a theatrical composer, part of his musical DNA.
“Even though I’m more of a “classical composer,” that really is the deepest part of my identity as a theatrical composer.”
- El Niño differs from Handel's Messiah, which treats the same nativity material entirely from the Bible written by men, because Adams and Peter Sellars used first-hand texts by women, especially Hispanic women from Mexico and Chile, to convey the actual experience of labor, birth, and motherhood that the male biblical authors could not know.
“Handel’s Messiah, which of course treats the same material, just comes from the Bible. And that’s all guys talking about it, and really, what do they know about labor and the pain of parturition and motherhood?”
Certain composers and musicians achieve distinctive greatness through sustained artistic evolution or singular vision.
- For the New York Philharmonic's 9/11 memorial On the Transmigration of Souls, Adams created a 'memory space' in which texts, words, and phrases float in musical space so the listener enters it like a great European cathedral and experiences private emotions; the texts came from handmade signs left by family members at Ground Zero and online memorial cards.
“I came up with the idea of what I called a memory space, where the various texts and words and phrases could float, so to speak, in musical space.”
- Philip Glass's music is very simple and easy to access and not difficult to perform, so conducting it produces a buzz from usually very large audiences, including people who wouldn't normally attend a classical concert; Glass is more widely known and recognized by name than any other classical composer, drawing packed halls.
“Philip’s music is very simple and very easy to access, so you get a nice buzz from, usually, a very large audience.”
- Adams stopped composing for and playing the clarinet partly because it has a very small amount of literature, with only a couple of great pieces by Mozart and a few by Brahms, and most of its role is being part of an orchestra; the most exciting current option for a clarinetist would be playing Klezmer music.
“it has a very small amount of literature. It has a couple of great pieces by Mozart and a few by Brahms, and really, most of the rest of the music is in the classical realm.”
- The original version of Shaker Loops used finger cues from the conductor, which Adams could realize satisfyingly but other conductors made strangely out of focus; in the later version he froze everything into traditional notation, losing flexibility but gaining a very satisfying fixed form.
“when another conductor did it, the shape was strangely out of focus. It’s not that the other conductor was incompetent. It was just that I had a very specific way of wanting to do it.”
- Morton Feldman's sui generis, slow, delicate, erotically sensuous music requires a particular kind of listener, a suspension of expectation, and a specific acoustical setting, and therefore probably does not survive in the aggressive, busy format of a standard orchestral subscription concert, which is why even admirers program it only in special contemporary contexts.
“It requires a certain kind of listener. It requires a certain, shall we say, suspension of expectation, and it requires a whole kind of acoustical setting.”
- Adams recommends the four-minute orchestral piece Short Ride in a Fast Machine, inspired by a terrifying sports-car ride, as the easiest entry point to his music because it is high-energy, enjoyable, and contains a lot of characteristic John Adams elements like driving pulse and colorful orchestration.
“the most easy entrance point into my music is a short orchestral piece called Short Ride in a Fast Machine... It has a lot of John Adams in it in terms of the driving pulse and colorful orchestration.”
- Though not a practicing Christian, Adams is drawn to biblical stories because they are archetypal, reflecting in myth and symbolism the deepest of human experience.
“I’m very drawn to some of these biblical stories because they’re archetypal. They reflect, in myth and symbolism, the deepest of our human experience.”
- Miles Davis had a career like Stravinsky, Beethoven, or Picasso, moving through many distinct periods from bop to a modal period with Zawinul and Hancock to a late African-influenced period asserting his racial identity in an unprecedented way; Adams cannot cherry-pick a peak but keeps returning to the lush Gil Evans big-band albums Miles Ahead and Sketches of Spain.
“Miles Davis had a career like Stravinsky or like Beethoven or like Picasso. He went through so many periods.”
- Although the US is controlled by popular culture with enormous reach and prestige, many of the greatest living classical musicians are American-born or naturalized (Yo-Yo Ma, Dudamel, Yuja Wang), America has some of the world's greatest orchestras and intelligent audiences, and the claim that American classical music is dying is false, since Europe faces the same problems of filling halls and lower musician pay.
“I keep hearing that classical music is dead or that it’s dying, but then I go to concerts and I have these incredible experiences”
- Pop music is strongly linked to periods in one's life, so people form intense sentimental attachments to the music they heard around age 20, likely bound up with recollections of romance, revelations, drugs, and lovers; this is a general pattern, with each generation measuring by the music of their youth.
“it’s so much linked to periods in your life, so that somebody who’s my age has a very, very strong sentimental attachment to music that you heard when you were 20.”
- Many bands of the 1960s and 70s, like Jefferson Airplane, became famous because of one or maybe two songs and then hobbled along and disappeared rather than sustaining greatness.
“Many of those bands in the 1960s and ’70s became famous because of one or maybe two songs, and then they kind of hobbled along and disappeared.”
- Robert Ashley is underappreciated because he is off the grid of conventional description: he called his works 'operas' wryly, but his real gifts lay in his self-written texts and droll delivery accompanied by Blue Gene Tyranny's bluesy gospel piano, evoking a special Americana of anonymous people in diners and gas stations, so Adams thinks of him in the literary rather than the musical realm.
“one of the things about Ashley is that he’s just off the grid when it comes to finding a conventional way to describe it.”
- Adams lives in California for its landscape, but it has become harder to live there as San Francisco is taken over by tech, suffers hectic urban development alongside the distressing situation of the unhoused, and parts of the state burn every summer due to climate change, producing a mixture of delight and extreme disappointment.
“San Francisco itself has become taken over by tech. And it just experiences this unpleasantly hectic urban development, which goes hand in hand with the very distressing situation of the unhoused.”
A written score is inherently reborn in each performance differently from pop's fixed recorded form.
- Classical music differs fundamentally from a pop recording because a written score is essentially a recipe that changes with every performance; different singers, conductors, and violinists give a completely new point of view, so the pieces are constantly being reborn rather than fixed in a single definitive form.
“when you write a score, you are essentially making a recipe for something, and it changes with every performance. It’s not like a recording by a pop group that’s always going to be the same.”
- When recordings were scarce (a single Mahler symphony might require months of waiting via the Schwann Catalog), each one felt special; today everything is instantly available via streaming and Kindle, so nothing is special anymore, and one must make a deliberate pact to cultivate a personal relationship with a few valuable works or risk short concentration spans and an inability to know what to value.
“Today, everything is available at all times... Nothing is special anymore.”
Artists must grapple with the anxiety of influence from towering predecessors while trusting good work endures.
- Adams considers 'ambition' an unhelpful term, identifying ambitious people by the fact that when you talk to them they are not even listening but thinking about their next move or their reputation; he distinguishes caring deeply whether his music reaches people from being ambitious, and trusts that good work will endure after he is gone.
“you can tell because when you’re talking to them, you see in their eyes that they’re not even listening to you. They’re thinking about their next move or what the world thinks of them.”
- Harold Bloom's coined phrase the 'anxiety of influence' captures how creators live under the shadow of the greats who preceded them; for Adams this manifests as worry about whether his work is even comparable to heavyweight predecessors like Beethoven, Bach, Mahler, and Stravinsky, and whether his ideas have already been thought of before.
“he intuited that we creators, whether we’re painters or novelists or filmmakers or composers — that we live, so to speak, under the shadow of the greats that preceded us.”