causal

Repression Depends on People Willing to Repress

A repressive apparatus is not a machine or AI but people who grew up in neighborhoods and villages alongside those they are ordered to repress; repression works only until the moment the people in it decide to stop—as when tsarist elite military units refused to shoot the striking workers in 1917 because the workers were the same peasants they came from—making the collapse a 'political bank run' that is impossible to predict but rooted in the loss of legitimacy.

causalpending

Speaker

Stephen Kotkin

Evidence Quote

“The army was told to shoot them. These are elite military units. Shoot these workers... The workers were peasants yesterday... They were the same people. The army decided not to shoot... There comes a moment where the people who are supposed to do the shooting decide not to shoot... You have this huge repressive apparatus, and it works until the moment the people in it decide not to do it anymore.”

Source

Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history— Dwarkesh Patel Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...