causal

Education as Sorting Versus Transformation

Education can be viewed either as a transforming system (students enter as clay and are shaped into something beautiful) or a sorting system (like a coin-counting machine that separates quarters, dimes, and nickels without changing them); people idealistically assume the clay model, but the reality is far more often the sorting model, since provable, durable, scalable examples of genuine transformation are very rare.

causalpending

Speaker

Arnold Kling

Evidence Quote

“It is very rare to see provable, durable, scalable examples of actual transformation, where you can see students being transformed rather than just sorted.”

Source

Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...