causal

What sounds scientific is historically contingent

What does or does not sound like science is a matter of history: the passive clockwork model sounds scientific today and the active mechanist model sounds less so only because science developed through a political division of labor in which questions of agency, purpose, and meaning were assigned to theology while science addressed proximate mechanism; one could imagine a parallel history in which restless clockwork sounds perfectly scientific.

causalpending

Speaker

Jessica Riskin

Evidence Quote

“what does or doesn't sound like science is a matter of history.”

Source

Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:34 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...