In Smith's solitary islander thought experiment, a person raised from birth with no human contact would have only likes and dislikes (tastes, preferences for birds or sunsets) but no properly moral sensibilities, because he would lack 'the mirror' society provides of one's own conduct. Interaction with others therefore constitutes moral agency, and isolation diminishes it.

normativepending

Speaker

James Otteson

Evidence Quote

“he doesn't have Smith says have the mirror that society gives to us of our own behavior”

Source

James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011— EconTalk
Created: 10/30/2026, 2:13:48 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...