normative

Supreme Court confirmations should probe views on cases

A genuinely useful confirmation process would ask nominees their views on already-decided cases and whether those cases were correct; the claim that this biases them is unpersuasive because one can hold and revise a view based on new information, and the notion that nominees' views should be hidden is profoundly undemocratic since they are political appointees who make law for society.

normativepending

Speaker

Jamal Greene

Evidence Quote

“The idea that they haven’t thought about these things or have no formed views, or that we shouldn’t be aware of what their views are, seems to me to be profoundly undemocratic.”

Source

Jamal Greene— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:24:33 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...