causal

Where Are You From Lands Differently by Status

The question 'Where are you from?' is often benign but lands very differently depending on the newcomer's status: a vulnerable, anxious new immigrant trying to 'pass'—especially when asked by someone they feel unequal with—experiences it as threatening, whereas a settled immigrant who has found their bearings can experience it as a welcome way to start friendships.

causalpending

Speaker

Roya Hakakian

Evidence Quote

“Oftentimes, the reasons are completely benign. But you feel vulnerable because you feel vulnerable, period. Because of the circumstances--your own brand-new circumstances as a newcomer.”

Source

Roya Hakakian on A Beginner's Guide to America— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...