Roya Hakakian on A Beginner's Guide to America
What this covers
Roya Hakakian, author and poet who immigrated to the United States from Iran at nineteen, speaks with Russ Roberts about her book A Beginner's Guide to America, offering an outsider's meditation on immigration, national identity, and what binds a diverse society. The conversation moves between Hakakian's personal experience of displacement and a broader argument about American belonging. She contends that involuntary immigrants arrive fundamentally broken and grieving—not as opportunists or threats—and that this condition shapes everything about the immigrant experience. Roberts engages as interlocutor, pressing on tensions between competing American narratives and the economics of immigration policy.
The discussion ranges across several interconnected claims. Hakakian argues that America's enduring strength lies not in racial or ethnic purity but in Values-Based Citizenship—shared commitment to founding principles of liberty, equality, and democratic participation. She traces America's Hazing Ritual, the recurring pattern of hostility toward each new immigrant wave, from the Irish and Chinese through to contemporary arrivals, and suggests this cycle is paradoxically reassuring: each group eventually belongs to a long shared history. The conversation examines how freedom and security in America—ordinary comforts invisible to the native-born—liberate cognitive and emotional capacity in those arriving from constraint. Hakakian challenges both the "everything is irredeemable evil" and "shut up, everything's fine" framings of American history, arguing instead for a nuanced narrative acknowledging imperfection while recognizing genuine progress. She also contests the notion that only highly skilled immigrants contribute, and connects immigrant gains to the centuries-long Black freedom struggle that reshaped American justice. Roberts raises practical questions about merit-based immigration and H-1B Visa programs, and both speakers grapple with how past wrongs constrain present policy choices.
Hakakian argues that involuntary immigration is fundamentally an experience of grief and brokenness rather than opportunism, and that America's enduring strength lies in binding diverse peoples through shared founding values rather than race or ethnicity.
- Immigrants arrive 'broken' and grieving, making the notion that they come to commit crimes incoherent
- America's comfort and security are unrecognized gifts that free mental space for higher pursuits
- Citizenship and national identity must rest on shared immovable values, not purity of race or ethnicity
Immigrants of all skill levels enrich America through diverse labor and sacrifice, not reducible to economic metrics or productivity measures.
- Ordinary, non-highly-skilled immigrants—driving Uber, mowing lawns, building buildings, caring for the elderly, picking fruit—enrich America's tapestry in innumerable ways just as all human beings do, often working three jobs for their children's futures, so the claim that only highly skilled immigrants make a contribution is mistaken.
“There are a lot of people who say, 'Oh, we should only take the highly skilled ones, the ones that are going to make a contribution,' as if everyday human beings aren't making a contribution.”
- Calling a person 'productive' is dangerous because it implies our value is what we make; productivity is important but it is only part of the story and not the source of human value—an immigrant's worth is not reducible to economic output measurable on paper.
“I think that word 'productive' is a dangerous word, right? It implies that our value is what we make. It's important. It's not our value, though.”
America must reject both simplistic narratives—irredeemable evil or uncritical celebration—and adopt a rich, historically differentiated story that acknowledges imperfection while genuinely improving.
- Condemning the United States for its policies is a valid starting point but a dangerous ending point; 'starting over' has a poor track record in human history because the people who end up in charge of starting over are not the people one would want in charge, so reform should fix things in ways that genuinely make them better rather than worse.
“Starting over doesn't have a good track record in human history, unfortunately. The people in charge of the starting over are not necessarily the people that you would like to see in charge.”
- America has two competing simplistic narratives—'America was formed in 1619 in evil and is irredeemable' versus 'everything's great, shut up'—neither of which works; the country needs a rich, nuanced narrative (exemplified by Hamilton and Hakakian's book) that acknowledges imperfection, commits to genuine improvement, and recognizes that history differs for the enslaved, the persecuted, and voluntary economic migrants.
“there's two competing narratives right now. One is: 'America was formed in 1619, in evil. It is irredeemable.'... The other narrative is: 'Everything's great. Shut up.' Those don't work well together. And, we need a nuanced one.”
Immigrants gain distinctive outsider insight into America precisely because they arrive from radically different worlds and experience transformative displacement.
- Because Hakakian arrived as a 'miserable wretch' from a very different world, she could see features of America that those born and immersed in it—'in the water'—do not notice, making the immigrant's outsider perspective a distinctive source of insight about the host society.
“because you were a miserable wretch when you came here and you came from a very different world, you were able to see things that those of us who were in the water don't necessarily notice”
- Some transformative experiences cannot be imagined from the outside—as in L.A. Paul's 'Vampire Problem,' where you cannot truly know what becoming a vampire is like until you become one—which is why the native-born cannot fully imagine the emotional turmoil and fear of the immigrant experience.
“what she calls the Vampire Problem--the fact that, before you're a vampire, you have certain vague idea of what it's like, but until you become one you can't really imagine it”
All people need liberation from various constraints, and positive vision matters more than opposition; voluntary reinvention differs from forced displacement.
- While black Americans and immigrants face unique challenges others cannot fully imagine, all people could use further liberation—everyone is a little bit enslaved, whether to screens, egos, or imperfection—so the emphasis should be on looking to what can be rather than only what has been, even though some have far more to overcome than others.
“all of us could use a little further liberation. I think we're all a little bit enslaved, still. It might be to our screens or to our egos or our imperfection.”
- A major problem in contemporary America for both immigrants and the native-born is that it is much easier to be against something than for it; when there is nothing one is 'for,' a hole opens, and the act of being 'against' expands to fill that hole as a coping mechanism for an empty life.
“it's much easier to be against something than for it. We're really good at 'against.' But, then there's a little hole if there's nothing here 'for.'”
- A person should 're-pot' themselves a few times in their lifetime—deliberately uprooting and replanting in a new environment—though there is a crucial difference between choosing to re-pot oneself and being wrenched involuntarily from the soil one was raised in.
“Somebody said to me: A person should re-pot themselves a few times in their lifetime.”