normative

Repugnant conclusion lives aren't human lives

The lives in Parfit's repugnant conclusion—where you're alive a few minutes, fed a potato, hear some Muzak, and pass away—are not human lives as we understand the term even if they look humanoid, so the difficulty is the same as comparing a billion bees to one person's migraine: moral realism can't handle utility comparisons across very different kinds of beings, and many of our intuitions about features of the utility distribution may be falsely implanted.

normativepending

Speaker

Tyler Cowen

Evidence Quote

“That moral realism can’t handle utility comparisons across very different kinds of beings.”

Source

Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:25:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...