causal

Prestige Stamps Of Approval Poorly Predict Lasting Quality

Relying on prestige stamps of approval (like a New York Times Book Review cover review) is unreliable because much that is highly praised at one point will not still be considered significant five or ten years later, while genuinely good books (like Stoner or The Last Samurai) can fall out of view and get lost in the margins amid the noise of new publishing.

causalpending

Speaker

Michael Orthofer

Evidence Quote

“I worry very much about people who rely on what gets that stamp of approval.”

Source

Michael Orthofer— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:55:16 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...