normative

Goal is managing disagreement, not being right

The question in rights conflicts is not whether anyone is right but whether disagreement is being managed in a way that produces social harmony and cohesion; the real problem is not that one side has rights wrong but that we disagree and lack agreement on how to resolve disagreement, so the judge's job is to manage pluralism, which doesn't lend itself to right-or-wrong answers.

normativepending

Speaker

Jamal Greene

Evidence Quote

“The problem is that we disagree, and we don’t agree on the way of resolving our disagreement either. The job of the judge, under those circumstances, is to manage disagreement, to manage pluralism.”

Source

Jamal Greene— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:24:33 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...