causal

Non-simultaneous chains require non-directed donors

Because contracts for kidneys are legally unenforceable (the law forbids valuable consideration), pairwise exchanges must be done simultaneously to prevent one pair from donating and not being reciprocated, requiring four operating rooms; but a non-directed donor allows chains where each pair receives a kidney before giving one, so a broken chain merely disappoints rather than harms, enabling long non-simultaneous chains that overcome logistical constraints.

causalpending

Speaker

Alvin Roth

Evidence Quote

“the reason those don't have to be done simultaneously is each pair gets a kidney before they give one. So, if a chain is broken, it's disappointing; but it's not a tragedy”

Source

Alvin Roth on Matching Markets— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...