The truth conditions for determining which predicates are essential versus contingent are unclear: we don't have a procedure for discovering agreement among phenomenologists, and when asked how one knows which predicates are essential, the only answer available is 'I introspected and found it to be true,' which is not a satisfactory answer and suggests there is no way to gesture at or communicate the content of intuitions.
causalpending
Evidence Quote
“how do we know which of these predicates are the essential ones help me out here i can imagine some which it seems fairly clear uh triangles have to have the property of having three sides”
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:30:12 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...