definition

Proportionality not utilitarianism resolves rights conflicts

Rather than utilitarianism, the standard for resolving rights conflicts is proportionality with respect to a set of values embedded in the existing legal tradition (free speech, racial equality, autonomy, democracy); there is no master key because that would presuppose a value hierarchy Greene rejects, so the judge's job is to assess whether values we share are being disproportionately affected in each individual case.

definitionpending

Speaker

Jamal Greene

Evidence Quote

“I don’t have a key, because the key presupposes some hierarchy between the values that I reject.”

Source

Jamal Greene— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:24:33 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...