causal

Aggression Debate Maps Onto Politics

The post-war debate over whether human aggression is innate (Lorenz, Tinbergen) or environmental/circumstantial gets mapped onto politics, and prehistory functions as a 'solution' to the unanswerable question of where violence comes from—letting us blame a vision of the past or improperly socialized exceptions rather than ourselves, modern technology, or geopolitics—producing mutually reinforcing arguments because no single one ever wins.

causalpending

Speaker

Stefanos Geroulanos

Evidence Quote

“I think that with the past a lot of the work that we see into prehistory it becomes a sort of solution... we can, you know, carefully blame a certain vision of the past, or we can blame exceptions... So we get all of these mutually reinforcing arguments because not one of them will ever win.”

Source

273 | Stefanos Geroulanos on the Invention of Prehistory— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...