273 | Stefanos Geroulanos on the Invention of Prehistory
What this covers
Historian Stefanos Geroulanos examines how scientific narratives of human prehistory have been shaped by present-day needs rather than evidence. Across three centuries, he traces a pattern: stories about human origins serve contemporary political, cultural, and social purposes—justifying colonial violence, eugenics, Nazism, and now Silicon Valley techno-optimism. The problem runs deeper than isolated instances of bias. Prehistory operates as a "gray zone" with sparse skeletal data and competing non-commensurate sciences (archaeogenetics, paleozoology, linguistics), creating perpetual room for rejected theories to resurface and for researchers to arrive with biases they cannot escape. Sean Carroll frames this as a human problem: scientists are subject to incentives and self-deception even in well-defined fields; in poorly bounded terrain like origins, fallibility is far worse.
Geroulanos illustrates how this happens across specific domains. In the 19th century, theories of "Stages of Progress" organized peoples into hierarchies—savage, barbarian, civilized—into which European colonizers could slot indigenous groups to justify violence. The concept of "Space Becomes Time" meant that geographical distance from Europe became interpreted as temporal primitiveness, collapsing geography into a false evolutionary ladder. Major foundational claims—from the Piltdown forgery fraudulently "discovered" by Charles Dawson and exposed by Kenneth Oakley, to the dominance of Asian origins over Charles Darwin's African theory—shifted largely for political rather than evidentiary reasons. Raymond Dart's violent theories of Australopithecus reached the public through screenwriter Robert Ardrey and shaped Kubrick's 2001, embedding primordial aggression into modern anxieties. Today, commercial pressure in Netflix-era documentaries produces exaggerated claims that collapse into the same traps.
Geroulanos proposes a remedy: treat the deep past as genuinely "other"—a "they" in an inaccessible world—rather than a "we" whose narratives grant legitimacy to present arrangements. Grounding human equality and obligation in present-day terms rather than in origin stories stops the past from doing political work. He illustrates this with George Bataille's reading of Lascaux: ancient painters rendered animals in detail but humans only as stick figures, suggesting they grasped death and representation—capacities that genuinely distinguish us. The talk ranges across how the Thin Veneer of Civilization became an unconscious phrase encoding contradiction, how post-war debates over innate aggression map prehistory onto politics as false solution, and how the newest version—Yuval Harari's vision endorsed by Bill Gates, President Obama, and Mark Zuckerberg—casts creative humans becoming "new gods" while ignoring ecological reality and the precarity of most people's actual futures.
Geroulanos argues that for the last few centuries our supposedly scientific accounts of human prehistory have been shaped less by evidence than by present-day cultural, political, and social purposes, and that recognizing this requires creating a hard separation between the deep past ('they') and ourselves ('we') so that the past stops conferring political legitimacy.
- Prehistory is a 'gray zone' with sparse data, leaving room for bias to roam and for theories to recur even after rejection.
- Stories of human origins have been deployed to justify colonial violence, eugenics, and Nazi extermination, as well as modern Silicon Valley techno-optimism.
- The remedy is to de-dramatize prehistory and ground human equality in present obligations rather than in narratives about deep origins.
Scientific fallibility from bias and incentive structures worsens in poorly defined fields.
- Scientists are human beings subject to biases, incentives, and temptations, so even in cut-and-dried claims like superconductivity they can fool themselves into asserting things that aren't true; this fallibility is far worse in poorly defined, hard-to-verify fields.
“scientists are actually not perfect reasoners. They're not perfectly rational. The world is rational... but we are human beings trying to figure out what those rules are, and we're subject to biases and incentives”