Market-cap-weighted indices must rebalance in response to stock market composition changes, and in doing so, index funds implicitly engage in market timing—specifically, buying high and selling low when issuers go public at high valuations and are bought back at low valuations.

causalpending

Speaker

Ben Felix

Evidence Quote

“Issuers, that's like companies listing on the public market, will generally want to issue stock when their valuation is high, when when they believe their valuation is high, and buy it back when their valuation is low. Index funds, in their effort to track the indices that reflect the market, end up buying high and selling low.”

Source

SpaceX and OpenAI: The Mega IPO Grift— Ben Felix
Created: 8/12/2026, 6:31:30 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...