
SpaceX and OpenAI: The Mega IPO Grift
What this covers
In this solo video, Ben Felix looks at what happens to index fund investors if SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic go public. He starts with the mechanics: the S&P 500 requires 12 months of public trading before inclusion, while the S&P Total Market Index has a fast-track entry that can add a stock within 5 days. He then turns to free float, noting that SpaceX plans to float under 5% of its equity. Most indices would weight it at roughly its $88 billion float or leave it out, and Nasdaq has just approved a rule change that introduces a float factor in place of its low-float cutoff.
The middle section is the historical record on IPOs). Felix cites the 1995 "new issues puzzle" paper, which found IPO investors earning about 5% a year against 12% for comparable established firms. He also cites a Dimensional Fund Advisors study of more than 6,000 IPOs, which found underperformance of about 2% a year, with the dot-com years as the main exception. The Renaissance IPO ETF serves as a live example. It has trailed VTI by over six points annualized and behaves like a portfolio of unprofitable, aggressively growing small stocks. A 2025 paper on index rebalancing puts the drag from index composition changes at 47 to 70 basis points a year.
The last stretch asks whether investors should instead seek private-market access. Felix is skeptical. He points to an SPV reportedly charging a 4% upfront fee plus 25% of profits, to murky ownership through special purpose vehicles), and to the problem of a liquid ETF holding an illiquid stake. He adds that survivorship bias distorts how private-company winners look, and that private equity has delivered net returns in line with public markets. His one modest alternative is that public companies making strategic private investments give indirect exposure.
Ben Felix argues that upcoming mega IPOs from companies like SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic will force index fund investors to buy overvalued stocks at unfavorable terms, creating a systematic drag on returns due to index fund mechanics and the historical underperformance of IPOs.
- IPOs have historically underperformed the market by 2-19 percentage points over 3-year periods, with low-float IPOs performing particularly poorly
- Index funds are mechanically forced to buy IPO shares regardless of valuation once included in indices, enabling front-running by intermediaries
- Index rebalancing to accommodate large IPOs creates a 47-70 basis point annual performance drag through buying high when companies go public
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A 2025 paper 'Index rebalancing and stock market composition: Do Indexes Time the Market' estimates that index rebalancing in response to composition changes creates a performance drag of 47 to 70 basis points per year relative to a delayed rebalancing approach.
“The 2025 paper index rebalancing and stock market composition, Do Indexes Time the Market, estimates that this timing ends up creating a performance drag of between 47 and 70 basis points per year relative to a delayed rebalancing approach.”
When everyone wants to buy something, either its price or the cost of accessing it will absorb a huge portion of the benefit you think you're going to get from investing in it.
“When everyone wants to buy something, either its price or the cost of accessing it will absorb a huge portion of the benefit you think you're going to get from investing in it.”
The S&P 500 requires stocks to have been trading on a public exchange for 12 months before inclusion, while the S&P Total Market Index allows for inclusion within 5 days for stocks meeting certain criteria through a mechanism called fast track entry.
“the S&P 500 requires a stock to have been trading on a public exchange for 12 months before inclusion, while the S&P Total Market Index allows for inclusion within 5 days for stocks that meet certain criteria”
Market-cap-weighted indices must rebalance in response to stock market composition changes, and in doing so, index funds implicitly engage in market timing—specifically, buying high and selling low when issuers go public at high valuations and are bought back at low valuations.
“Market-cap-weighted indices must rebalance in response to stock market composition changes, which in some cases can include IPOs. In doing so, index funds implicitly engage in market timing. The problem is that it tends to be really bad market timing.”
Private companies like SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic would rank among the largest companies in major indices if they went public, and index funds would be forced to buy their stock regardless of price.
“Private companies like SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic would rank among the largest companies if they went public, and index funds would be forced to buy their stock”
Low-float IPOs for high-revenue companies show constrained supply driving early price spikes followed by significant underperformance, suggesting that limited float amplifies initial demand but doesn't sustain valuation.
“suggesting that constrained supply may drive early price spikes, but tends to be followed by significant underperformance”
Most IPOs are terrible investments, with historically poor returns compared to the broader market.
“the problem is that most IPOs are terrible investments”
Unless an investor is an employee or otherwise has direct access to a company's shares, financial intermediaries with access are unlikely to give access to the equity on terms better for the investor than for the intermediary.
“unless you're an employee or otherwise have direct access to the company's shares, financial intermediaries that do have access are not typically going to give you access to the equity on terms that are better for you than they are for the intermediary.”
Index funds are forced to gobble up whatever stocks are included in the index regardless of price, lacking the discretion that regular investors have to avoid overvalued securities.
“If you're an investor, you probably don't want to buy an overpriced stock, but index funds don't have that kind of discretion. They're forced to gobble up whatever is included in the index regardless of its price.”
The Renaissance IPO ETF, which invests in large US IPOs at listing and sells after three years, has underperformed VTI by more than six percentage points annualized since inception in October 2013.
“The Renaissance IPO ETF exclusively invests in large US IPOs when they list and then sells the shares after they've been public for three years. It has underperformed VTI, which tracks the total US market, by more than six percentage points annualized since inception in October 2013.”
SpaceX plans to float less than 5% of its equity, much lower than the average IPO, which would create indexing problems because most indices would weight it at its float of 88 billion or exclude it altogether.
“As reported by the Financial Times, SpaceX plans to float less than 5% of its equity, much lower than the average IPO. With a $1.75 trillion valuation, but only a 5% float, most indices would weight it at its float of 88 billion, and many would actually exclude it altogether.”
Nasdaq currently has a 10% minimum float requirement but recently approved rule changes to eliminate the low float cutoff and introduce a float factor in their weighting of low float stocks.
“Nasdaq currently has a 10% minimum float and weight stocks based on the value of all listed shares of the company with no regard for free float, which is unique, but they recently approved rule changes following a public consultation to speed up IPO inclusion, eliminate the low float cutoff, and introduce a float factor in their weighting of low float stocks.”
The Roundhill Magnificent Seven ETF (ticker AAPL?) bought into SpaceX through an SPV in December 2024, creating unique practical issues as a liquid ETF holding a large stake in an illiquid asset.
“Some ETFs have gotten exposure to SpaceX shares either directly or through special purpose vehicles. One example that has attracted a lot of attention is the ER Shares Private Public Crossover ETF. It bought into SpaceX through an SPV in December 2024.”
Companies tend to go public when insiders believe the stock is overvalued or at least highly valued, making the timing of IPO entry precisely the wrong moment for new investors.
“Companies tend to go public when they think they can sell their stock at a high price, meaning the moment you can buy their stock on the secondary market is precisely when the insiders believe it's overvalued or at least nicely valued.”
Public companies make strategic investments into private companies, providing a path for public market investors to gain some exposure to private markets without the direct access problems.
“Some good news is that while it's generally difficult to get access to the private company shares that you really want, a lot of public companies make strategic investments into private companies. Public market investors are not entirely locked out of private markets.”
There are questions about who owns what due to the complicated structures of private company investment SPVs, and there are stories of outright fraud.
“There are also questions about who owns what due to the complicated structures and of course there are stories of outright fraud.”
There is a huge amount of survivorship bias in private company outcomes—for every SpaceX or OpenAI, there are thousands of companies that did not grow or failed entirely, with this skewness being even more pronounced in private markets than in public markets.
“There's a huge amount of survivorship bias in private company outcomes. For every SpaceX or OpenAI that we hear about, there are thousands of companies that did not grow or failed entirely. This skewness exists in public markets, too, but it's even more brutal, even more pronounced in private markets.”
The fees and costs associated with private company investments can often absorb the financial benefits of owning them, as exemplified by private equity funds which have delivered net-of-fee returns in line with public markets.
“Additionally, the fees and costs associated with private company investments can often absorb the financial benefits of owning them. This has been true with private equity funds in general, which have delivered net of fee returns in line with public markets.”
A 1995 paper coined the term 'new issues puzzle' after finding that companies issuing stock from 1970 to 1990 tended to be poor investments, with investors in IPOs receiving average returns of only 5% per year versus 12% for similar established firms.
“The consistent pattern of IPO underperformance even has a name. It's the new issues puzzle, coined in a highly cited 1995 paper, which found that companies issuing stock from 1970 to 1990 tended to be poor investments.”
A 2019 Dimensional Fund Advisors study of over 6,000 IPOs from 1991 to 2018 found that a portfolio of IPOs generally underperformed the market and small cap index by about 2% per year, with the main exception being the 1992-2000 period when tech IPOs outperformed due to the dot-com boom.
“A more recent 2019 study from Dimensional Fund Advisors looked at the first year secondary market performance of more than 6,000 IPOs from 1991 to 2018 and found that a portfolio of IPOs generally underperformed the market and a small cap index by about 2% per year.”
Investors are so eager to get a piece of SpaceX that, at least in the case of XOVR, they got burned despite SpaceX's reported value appreciation.
“Investors are so eager to get a piece of SpaceX that, at least in this case, they got burned.”
Free float is the proportion of a company's shares available for purchase in the public equity market, and most major indices have minimum float requirements and weight stocks by their public float.
“Free float is the proportion of a company's shares that are available for purchase in the public equity market. Most major indices have a minimum float requirement and weight stocks by their public float.”
A Wall Street Journal report documented a special purpose vehicle offering exposure to SpaceX that charged a 4% upfront fee with an additional fee of 25% of future profits.
“One special purpose vehicle reported on by Wall Street Journal had a 4% upfront fee with an additional fee of 25% of future profits.”
The Renaissance IPO ETF behaves like a portfolio of small stocks with high prices, low profitability, and aggressive asset growth, exhibiting the Fama-French junk factor characteristics.
“And as expected, it behaves like a portfolio of small stocks with high prices, low profitability, and aggressive asset growth.”
For context on valuation multiples, the highest price-to-sales ratio for an S&P 500 constituent today is Palantir's 73 times, while the S&P 500 index trades at a P/S of 3.1 times.
“For context, the highest price-to-sales ratio for an S&P 500 constituent today is Palantir's 73 times, while the index as a whole trades at a price-to-sales of 3.1 times.”
The front-running of index fund IPO purchases by intermediaries is analogous to ticket scalping for concerts and sports events, and represents a 'shadow tax' largely paid by index fund investors.
“The authors call this a shadow tax largely paid by index fund investors. It's like ticket scalpers for concerts and sports events.”
The cynical view is that Nasdaq is changing its index rules to win SpaceX over in an effort to get their listing on the Nasdaq exchange, which would be good for SpaceX, its early investors, and Nasdaq, but potentially comes at the expense of Nasdaq 100 index fund investors.
“The cynical view on this is that Nasdaq is changing the Nasdaq 100 index rules to win SpaceX over in an effort to get their listing on the Nasdaq exchange. Including them in the index would force significant index fund buying, which likely ends up being good for SpaceX, its early investors, and Nasdaq, but potentially comes at the expense of Nasdaq 100 index fund investors.”
Jeff Tack of Morningstar Research Services noted that when it comes to investing, the more you covet something, the more you should question your desire to own it in the first place.
“As Jeff Tack, managing director for Morningstar Research Services, widely noted in his analysis of XOVR, when it comes to investing, the more you covet something, the more you should probably question your desire to own it in the first place.”
The performance drag from index rebalancing represents a lasting negative effect on index fund investor portfolios that could have been avoided had the index fund prioritized expected returns rather than tracking error to its index.
“In other words, there is a lasting negative effect on your portfolio that could have been avoided had your index fund prioritized expected returns rather than tracking error to its index.”
Index fund investors have two main options: accept the IPO cost and continue with index funds, or look at alternatives like Dimensional funds that are low-cost and broadly diversified but don't auto-invest in IPOs.
“You can either accept it and carry on or look at alternatives like Dimensional funds that are similarly low-cost and broadly diversified, but don't auto invest in IPOs.”
The reason the ER Shares Private Public Crossover ETF has lost money despite SpaceX appreciation is complicated and involves multiple factors, which is itself part of the problem with private company investment vehicles.
“There are multiple reasons for this and it gets complicated quickly, and that's part of the problem.”
Ben Felix does not personally use index funds or recommend them for PWL Capital clients, instead using Dimensional Fund Advisors funds which are similar to index funds but don't track an index and intentionally avoid investing in IPOs for about a year after listing.
“Listen, I'm a huge fan of index funds, but this issue right here is one of the reasons that I don't use them personally or for the clients of PWL Capital. I use funds from Dimensional Fund Advisors, which are a lot like index funds, but don't track an index and intentionally avoid investing in IPOs for about a year after the company lists.”
High valuations are generally associated with low expected future returns.
“In general, high valuations are associated with a low expected future returns.”
Dimensional funds intentionally tilt away from the junk characteristics that IPOs tend to display more generally.
“They also intentionally tilt away from the the junk that IPOs tend to behave like more generally.”
Ben Felix was not paid by Dimensional or anyone else to recommend their products and gains nothing from users choosing their products.
“To be clear, my firm PWL Capital does use Dimensional funds, but I was not paid by Dimensional or anyone else to say this, and I gain nothing from you using their products.”