factual
Modal Counterparts Do Not Generate Moral Obligation
Under David Lewis's modal realism, where possible worlds and one's counterparts are real, the ethical implication is paradoxical: if I do good, my counterparts must do the corresponding bad to saturate all possibilities, so rather than taking counterparts into account, one might be morally obligated not to, since a line of thought suggests nothing one does matters because all possibilities are realized anyway.
factualpending
Speaker
Agnes CallardEvidence Quote
“I kind of think I’m actually morally obligated not to because I go down a chain of thought that says it doesn’t matter what I do because all the possibilities will be real in any case.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:05:06 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...