factual

Modal Counterparts Do Not Generate Moral Obligation

Under David Lewis's modal realism, where possible worlds and one's counterparts are real, the ethical implication is paradoxical: if I do good, my counterparts must do the corresponding bad to saturate all possibilities, so rather than taking counterparts into account, one might be morally obligated not to, since a line of thought suggests nothing one does matters because all possibilities are realized anyway.

factualpending

Speaker

Agnes Callard

Evidence Quote

“I kind of think I’m actually morally obligated not to because I go down a chain of thought that says it doesn’t matter what I do because all the possibilities will be real in any case.”

Source

Agnes Callard— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:05:06 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...