causal
Failure Gives Communism a Second Wind
A paradoxical feature of communism is that its failures don't discredit it but give it a 'second wind': once horrors are acknowledged and denounced, believers conclude it was the individual (Stalin, Mao) who was at fault rather than the system, so de-Stalinization under Khrushchev subtracted Stalin while keeping collective farms, state ownership, planning, and the party monopoly—renewing belief that persisted through Gorbachev, and the same pattern reappears with Xi Jinping despite his family's suffering under Mao.
causalpending
Speaker
Stephen KotkinEvidence Quote
“Instead of saying that, they say, "We get a chance to do it right this time without the evil Stalin who messed it all up." The Khrushchev thing, the revelation of the horrors, the denunciation of the horrors, ironically gives you the second wind of belief in the system that's going to last right through Gorbachev... It's never the system at fault, it's Stalin at fault. It's never the system at fault, it's Mao's mistakes or excesses.”
Source
Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history— Dwarkesh Patel PodcastCreated: 6/13/2026, 3:31:58 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...