factual

Amish Rumspringa and the liberal test of freedom

In the Amish Rumspringa, teenagers spend a year or two living among non-Amish before choosing whether to re-enter the community; over 90% choose to return, yet Deneen's liberal Princeton colleagues regarded this as proof of brainwashing rather than free choice, insisting that genuine freedom would require a roughly 50/50 coin-flip outcome—revealing that liberalism treats any deep prior formation as a constraint on authentic free choice.

factualpending

Speaker

Patrick Deneen

Evidence Quote

“they thought that unless people were choosing more or less on the basis of a coin flip whether or not they would reenter the Amish community that they weren't actually exercising freedom.”

Source

Patrick Deneen on Why Liberalism Failed— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:04:26 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...