Patrick Deneen on Why Liberalism Failed
What this covers
Patrick Deneen, a political scientist at Notre Dame, makes the case in conversation with Russ Roberts that liberalism—understood as the modern project of liberating the individual from the constraints of tradition, family, and religion—rests on a fundamentally false conception of human freedom and has produced the opposite of what it promised. The discussion spans the long intellectual history of liberal thought, from Thomas Hobbes and John Locke through to contemporary thinkers, examining how a redefinition of liberty from classical self-rule oriented toward virtue into the unobstructed satisfaction of desire has remade Western civilization. Deneen argues that what appears to be a titanic political battle between left and right is actually two versions of the same project: both classical liberalism and progressive liberalism aim to liberate the autonomous individual and both expand state power to accomplish it.
The conversation explores how individualism and state growth as complements—the state grows precisely to replace the formative institutions (family, church, community) that once both supported and limited people. This dissolution has not produced undifferentiated freedom but rather class-stratified atomization and unprecedented loneliness in wealthy nations. Deneen traces how liberalism treats tradition as arbitrary constraint rather than accumulated wisdom, and how it casts nature as an obstacle to be mastered rather than a limit to be respected. The discussion examines specific ground: the paradox of sexual liberation producing expanded state adjudication, the gap between material plenty and human contentment, and the Amish Rumspringa as a case study in what counts as authentic choice. Moving toward recovery, Deneen proposes that rebuilding formative institutions and developing a post-liberal political philosophy grounded in self-limitation will be necessary, likely within two decades rather than centuries.
Deneen argues that liberalism—the shared project of both the political left and right—rests on a false conception of freedom as the absence of constraint, and that pursuing this ideal has paradoxically expanded the state, dissolved the formative institutions (family, community, religion, culture) that orient people toward the good, and produced atomized, lonely, class-stratified individuals; recovery requires rebuilding culture and a post-liberal political philosophy grounded in self-limitation.
- Classical (right) and progressive (left) liberalism are two sides of one coin: both aim at liberating the autonomous individual and both empower the state to do it.
- Individualism and state expansion grow together because the state replaces the civil-society institutions that once both supported and limited individuals.
- Liberalism redefined liberty from self-rule oriented to virtue into the unobstructed satisfaction of desire, severing freedom from responsibility and from nature.
Liberalism fundamentally misunderstands human freedom and nature as obstacles to master rather than limits to respect.
- Liberalism inaugurated a new understanding of liberty: whereas the classical and Christian tradition defined liberty as ruling oneself according to the good (a life of virtue with self-limitation), early modern thinkers like Hobbes and Locke redefined liberty as the absence of external constraint on the fulfillment of desire, transforming the purpose of government.
“liberty becomes understood as the absence of obstacle to the fulfillment of our desires, or will, or appetite. So that it becomes redefined as the absence of external constraint.”
- A core assumption of liberalism is the 'self-making self'—the idea that the individual makes him or herself—but this is a fundamentally false understanding of the human person, because we are creatures bound in relationships and the self is in many ways the sum of those relationships; self-control and self-discipline require external formation and a training ground that precedes the adult's own will.
“a core assumption of liberalism is the idea of the self-making self... It's the idea that the individual makes him or herself.”
- Liberalism begins not with the disposition to distinguish good traditions from bad ones, but with the ground assumption that tradition, because it is unchosen by the individual and prior to the age of cognizance, is by its nature arbitrary and presumptively illegitimate—incompatible with the ideal of the self-making self that must author itself from scratch.
“liberalism is, as a philosophy... begins with a kind of ground assumption that tradition is, by its nature it's arbitrary, not chosen by the individual; and therefore presumptively illegitimate.”
- Liberalism is an unprecedented civilizational experiment—disassembling traditional institutions, tradition itself, and culture while unleashing scientific powers to produce the autonomous self-making self—and enough evidence has now accumulated to conclude it was based on a false conception of human freedom, a false understanding of human nature, and a false understanding of the relationship between humans and nature, such that we have to start anew.
“we are in the midst of an experiment that had never been tried before in the history of the world. Which is: let's disassemble all of these traditional institutions, the idea of tradition itself, the idea of culture.”
- At the heart of the liberal project is the idea that there are two great obstacles to liberty—other people (addressed by political and economic systems and the dismantling of tradition) and nature; nature is recast not as continuous with human nature but as an object for complete mastery and manipulation, a continuous argument running from Bacon and Hobbes through Locke and Dewey.
“There are two great obstacles to our liberty. The first is other people... But, the other great obstacle to this understanding of liberty is nature. Nature becomes the great obstacle.”
Dissolving traditional institutions promised liberation but created state expansion, loneliness, and class-based disadvantage instead.
- The dissolution of formative institutions has not produced undifferentiated liberation but a class-based advantage: young people from well-constituted families and communities (concentrated at elite institutions like Princeton, Georgetown, Notre Dame) increasingly hold advantages over those who cannot form such institutions, while these institutions have been decimated in the lower and working classes.
“now we have, in particular, a condition and a situation where it's especially young people who come from families and to some extent communities that are well-constituted, that now have increasingly advantages over those who don't.”
- Individualism and the growth of the central state are not opposites but grow together: the realization of the autonomous individual requires the state to expand and centralize in order to fill in for the functions of civil society (family, community, church) that it displaces, so the explosion of individualism (declining family, child-bearing, associations, religious affiliation) coincides with extraordinary state centralization.
“the individual only comes into being once you have this kind of large, expansion of and increasing centralization and empowering of the central state.”
- Against Steven Pinker-style optimism, Deneen argues the wealthiest countries exhibit unprecedented and extraordinary levels of loneliness—roughly half the population reporting loneliness as their greatest challenge—showing that although liberalism delivered the material conditions Bacon promised, material goods are not the ultimate source of human contentment, which lies in good relationships.
“One of the striking things about, one of the measures one sees today in the wealthiest countries in the world are the levels of loneliness that are just extraordinary, and unprecedented in our civilization.”
- The liberation of individuals to govern their own sexual choices, paradoxically, empowers the state: as in loco parentis customs and adult formation on college campuses were demolished, the absence of shaping norms left a vacuum now filled by a juridical state apparatus adjudicating questions of consent—so dismantling 'oppressive customs' produced not a sexual nirvana but an expanded Leviathan.
“the liberation of the individual in this instance, to govern their own kinds of choices when it comes to something so deeply personal as sexuality, now, actually, ends up empowering the State in interesting ways.”
- During the Great Depression, despite greater poverty and fewer opportunities, there was strong encouragement and support for marriage, family, and human formation through churches, the Boy Scouts, and a broad set of egalitarian institutions—supports now broken down for the working class, making basic life formation harder than it was even for poorer people in the past.
“During the Great Depression, for example: there was a great encouragement and support for marriage and for family and formation of a kind of human life that was encouraged through church and Boy Scouts and, again, the broad set of institutions that existed in the country.”
Liberalism severs freedom from responsibility and treats all prior formation as arbitrary constraint rather than moral guidance.
- Modern society combines the worst of classical and progressive liberalism: freedom defined as absence of constraint to satisfy desire, coupled with the belief that the consequences of one's choices are not one's own responsibility but society's; only when freedom and responsibility are bound tightly together is freedom properly understood, and severing them produces societal irresponsibility and an infantilized populace.
“freedom without the responsibility of the consequences of the choices you make is, leads to a condition in which you have, broadly speaking, societal irresponsibility.”
- Culture (etymologically tied to cultivate and to cult/religion) is the domain where the negotiation between unfettered human liberty and the constraints of the natural world takes place—governing and guiding human capacities such as sexuality; liberalism, however, deconstructs culture and replaces it with an 'anti-culture' that presumes any expansion of individual liberty is good and any constraint unjustified, making it impossible to debate the broader consequences of individual choice.
“culture has been that domain in which the negotiation, in particular between this possibility of unfettered human liberty and the constraints of the natural world was largely negotiated.”
- Pre-modern institutions (family, community, religion, culture) did not so much restrain choice as orient people toward making good choices, building within their souls the capacity to choose well; civilization rests on the premise that there are good and bad choices, but liberalism has treated even these formative institutions as arbitrary, unjust authority and discarded their formational role.
“it's not so much that they restrained choice as such. It's that, I think these kinds of institutions oriented people toward making good choices.”
- In the Amish Rumspringa, teenagers spend a year or two living among non-Amish before choosing whether to re-enter the community; over 90% choose to return, yet Deneen's liberal Princeton colleagues regarded this as proof of brainwashing rather than free choice, insisting that genuine freedom would require a roughly 50/50 coin-flip outcome—revealing that liberalism treats any deep prior formation as a constraint on authentic free choice.
“on the order of 90-plus percent, the Amish people having tasted the fruits of this vice and freedom, they choose to re-enter the Amish community.”
Classical and progressive liberalism are two sides of the same coin, both pursuing individual liberation through different means.
- Economics has lost the ancient recognition—understood by Aristotle and Machiavelli—that the economy serves a political end, so that an economy generating titanic inequality (as in Tyler Cowen's Average Is Over vision of 10-15% wealthy and 85-90% living in favela-like conditions) will have very bad political repercussions; the question 'What is economics for?' must be restored by reconnecting economics to political philosophy if a flourishing order is to survive.
“if an economy is generating titanic forms of inequality, it's likely to have very bad political repercussions. This is understood by Aristotle; it's understood by Machiavelli.”
- Hayek distinguished a problematic anti-traditional 'French' liberalism (Rousseau, Condorcet, Hobbes as honorary Frenchman) from a tradition-friendly 'English' liberalism (Burke, Hume, Tocqueville as honorary Englishman); this self-limiting liberalism—which recognized that non-liberal, pre-liberal understandings were needed to limit liberal ideology—was the ground condition for American success for its first several decades, but over time America has conformed more to its liberal ideology than to those pre-liberal practices.
“Hayek himself had a more sophisticated understanding of this, because he understood and he broke down what he saw a kind of a problematic form of liberalism, which he called French Liberalism”
- What appears to be the titanic political battle of our time—classical liberalism versus progressive liberalism—is actually two sides of the same coin: both share the goal of liberating the individual and merely disagree over the means (limiting the state and expanding markets versus using the state to remove economic injustices that block individual liberty).
“what we think of as the great and titanic political battle of our time--kind of classical liberal versus progressive liberal--is actually two sides of the same coin.”
Popular political upheavals signal grassroots rejection of liberalism, creating an opening for post-liberal leadership and community-based renewal.
- Recovery requires, paradoxically within liberalism, deciding to create culture from the bottom up—families, communities, and churches building anew—alongside a new post-liberal political philosophy grounded in a different understanding of freedom and new forms of self-limitation appealing to people who have lived without guideposts; Deneen now expects the need for this post-liberal vision within roughly 20 years rather than centuries, given the accelerating dissolution of the liberal order.
“in the first instance I think there's a need to begin from the bottom up: For families, communities, churches, and so forth to build anew. But I also argue that there is a need for a new political philosophy.”
- Progressives invert classical liberalism's stance on nature: while arguing for environmentalism and protecting the natural world, they are the most ardent advocates for complete mastery of the human body—especially reproductive technologies—detaching the idea that human beings have a nature connected to the natural world and insisting there should be no limit to altering the body.
“while today's progressives argue we should be environmentalists and concerned with the stuff of the world, they are also the most ardent in terms of arguing for the complete mastery of the human body--especially reproductive processes”
- The electoral upheavals in Europe and the United States, which upset Deneen's academic colleagues, are best read as inchoate signs of a percolating-from-below rejection of the liberal trajectory; Deneen hopes these will generate a new and better leadership class capable of negotiating between the prosperous and those left behind, by conceiving of the nation as a community of communities rather than an arena of globalized liberal ideology.
“the kinds of electoral activity and consequences and outcomes that you see in Europe today and even in the United States--oddly enough I see these as kinds of signs of inchoate and somewhat articulate signs of a certain rejection of this liberal trajectory.”
- Ideological thinking is defined by the inability to recognize how feedback from reality contradicts one's beliefs; just as Communism kept proclaiming economic improvement while people queued for toilet paper, today's elite circles hold an ideology that makes them immune to seeing how the breakdown of institutions—celebrated as progress—has produced the populist blowback (Trump, Brexit, European populism) they dismiss as a temporary deviation from the arc of history.
“this is what strikes me as ideological thinking, is the inability to recognize how the feedback from reality contradicts the ideological beliefs.”
Both liberalisms share the false belief that politics can be solved through technique, ignoring human frailty and the art of prudence.
- Both sides of liberalism share what Bertrand de Jouvenel called the 'Myth of the Solution'—the belief that the problems of politics can ultimately be solved, specifically through the elimination of politics via the application of the right technique, constitution, or state program—whereas politics is better understood, per Vaclav Havel, as the art of the possible, defined by the frailty and imperfection of human beings.
“What the political philosopher Bertrand de Jouvenal called the 'Myth of the Solution': that we can ultimately solve all of the problems of politics.”
- Dewey's contrast between the 'savage' who passively accepts nature and the 'civilized' man who transforms the environment (irrigating the desert so the wilderness blossoms) presents a false dichotomy that infects the classical liberal disposition—forcing a choice between backward traditionalism and forward-thinking innovation—whereas prudence and judgment can recognize nature as a real limit we and future generations depend upon, without collapsing into either pole.
“this division of the world into these two choices seems to me to be very much a kind of false dichotomy. And it's one that I'm afraid too often affects those of the classical liberal disposition”