causal
Vote share tracks historical, not current, manufacturing
Current Democratic vote share shows no relationship with present-day manufacturing employment share, but shows a striking positive relationship with manufacturing employment share from the 1880s and 1910s Censuses — because the dense proletarian housing built before the automobile remains and keeps attracting Left-leaning residents even in places like downtown Cleveland with no manufacturing left.
causalpending
Speaker
Jonathan RoddenEvidence Quote
“there's no relationship at all. But if you go back in the 1880s Census or the 1910 Census... you see this striking positive relationship between historical manufacturing employment and current Democratic vote share.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:35 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...