causal

Guilds functioned as exclusionary cartels

Guilds fundamentally sought the benefit of existing members, and because restricting entry raises prices they behaved like mini cartels, excluding women, Jews, poor boys, migrants, and people of the wrong skin color (a Spanish cobbler's guild barred boys darker than quince jelly), so the damage they did greatly outweighed any benefits.

causalpending

Speaker

Sheilagh Ogilvie

Evidence Quote

“I think definitively the damage greatly outweighed the benefits”

Source

Sheilagh Ogilvie— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:18:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...