causal

The Myth of Innate Philosophical 'It'

Women leave philosophy faster than men not because they are less interested but because analytic philosophy wrongly treats early performance as evidence of an innate 'it' that makes a good philosopher; since good philosophers are actually those who work hard with widely-distributed traits, teachers should stop signaling that poor early performance means a student lacks this nonexistent gift, and should instead tell students to push on and seek help.

causalpending

Speaker

Kwame Anthony Appiah

Evidence Quote

“Since it’s false that there’s some it that people have that makes them successful in philosophy, we should not be communicating this.”

Source

Kwame Anthony Appiah— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:27:49 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...