The Tootsie Roll vs IBM historical example illustrates that cheap, steady, share-buyback-focused companies can dramatically outperform popular, expensive companies over decades despite appearing to underperform during the growth company's popularity; this suggests current mega-cap tech stocks (which are expensive) might be analogous to IBM (which appeared great but underperformed cheaper alternatives).

normativepending

Speaker

Tobias Carlisle

Evidence Quote

“Tootsie Roll had massively outperformed IBM... in this market... aren't the mag seven... IBM... aren't they Tootsie Roll... I'd much rather have a portfolio of Tootsie Rolls [53:14-53:44]”

Source

Value Had One of Its Worst Periods in History | What Data Tells Us Comes Next— Excess Returns
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:08:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...