causal

First-Come-First-Served Justifies Nativism

The principle of first-come-first-served, intuitive in queues like McDonald's, becomes a powerful justification for nativism when extended to citizenship ('we were here first, immigrants must go to the back of the line'); but citizenship is not scarce, so unlike scarce goods that require ordering, citizenship could be granted to many people simultaneously without harm, making the queue logic inappropriate.

causalpending

Speaker

Elizabeth Cohen

Evidence Quote

“I think the best move is to say that we queue when we have to give things out in order, which is not the case with citizenship, we do not... There's not a scarcity of citizenship. So we could give out a whole bunch of citizenship simultaneously, and it would not matter at all”

Source

199 | Elizabeth Cohen on Time and Other Political Values— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:21:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...