What this covers

Elizabeth Cohen and Sean Carroll examine how time functions as a political value and why institutional theory has treated it as invisible. Cohen argues that time is fundamentally distinct from material goods: it is finite, incommensurable—once wasted, it cannot be restored through compensation—and yet political philosophy has devoted almost no serious attention to how institutions distribute or consume it. The conversation ranges from Thomas Jefferson's belief that constitutions should expire and be remade on generational timescales, grounded in actuarial calculations, to contemporary examples like administrative burden in tax filing or the cascading costs of misdemeanor prosecutions for people of color. Cohen contends that when similarly-situated citizens are made to wait unequally or serve longer sentences based on race, political institutions implicitly assign moral value to their time—and thereby to their personhood—a claim liberal theory cannot justify.

The discussion moves through how democratic theory and capitalism both emerged from the Scientific Revolution's shift toward predicting the future and managing risk. Cohen traces the tension between formal rights and the material constraints that prevent people from exercising them equally: affluent and poor citizens may have identical legal time, but real opportunity to use it freely differs sharply. She proposes that temporal formulas—like naturalization requirements that combine residence duration, language, civics knowledge, and adjustable time credits—work better than raw time thresholds because they acknowledge time as a flawed proxy for the values we actually care about. The podcast also explores how citizens develop psychological attachment to their place in a queue and examines whether first-come-first-served logic—intuitive for scarce goods—has been wrongly applied to citizenship through nativist framing.

Sharpest takeaway

Cohen argues that political theory has neglected time as a distinct, finite, and incommensurable good, and that political institutions should explicitly value and protect citizens' time rather than wasting it or distributing temporal burdens unequally.

  • Time is an incommensurable good that cannot be restored once wasted, unlike material goods
  • Treating similarly-situated people's time unequally assigns unjust moral value to persons
  • Temporal formulas (combining time with other factors) are better proxies than time alone for things like citizenship

The argument · threads2 threads · 27 claims
0.85

Human lifespan is a finite quantity making time-wasting a legitimate grievance.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The average human lifespan is roughly three billion heartbeats — a large but very finite number — which is why having one's time wasted is a legitimate grievance.

    “the average human lifespan is three billion heartbeats... it's a big number, but it's not an infinite number”

0.44

Time holds exceptional centrality in human language and thought.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Time is the most-used noun in the English language.

    “One of the favorite anecdotes is the time is the most used now in the English language”