normative

Settlements Security Requires Considering Neighbors' Goodwill

The Israeli-nationalist case for settlements fails to account for two parts of the calculus: that allowing your neighbors to feel a certain way about their neighbors is itself an element of security (building in total disregard breeds ill will, and world opinion matters), and that the endgame assumption—that Palestinians will eventually be reconciled or absorbed if their standard of living is high enough—does not work, since enfranchising them makes a Jewish state hard to imagine.

normativepending

Speaker

Rabbi David Wolpe

Evidence Quote

“the idea that ultimately the population around you will be reconciled to this in one way or another... doesn’t work for me.”

Source

Rabbi David Wolpe— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...