causal

Unpredictable Does Not Mean Non-Deterministic

The biggest mistake people make in inferring free will from chaos is conflating unpredictability with indeterminism: non-linear, chaotic, emergent systems mean we will never have full predictive power (we can't say which of three kids in a bad environment becomes a murderer, only that they are 47 times more likely than a suburban kid), but the absence of prediction does not mean there were no causal gears—it just means we don't know how they work.

causalpending

Speaker

Robert Sapolsky

Evidence Quote

“that doesn't mean there weren't gears there. Just because we don't know how they work, doesn't mean it just happened for no reason.”

Source

Robert Sapolsky on Determinism, Free Will, and Responsibility— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:07:06 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...