normative

Enhancement Debate Is About Equity Not Biology

The enhancement debate over editing to boost an already-healthy trait (like making average muscles unusually strong) is driven more by concerns about societal equity, meritocracy, and unfair advantage than by the transformation itself—since we already enhance via nutrition and training and some people are simply born lucky—except where editing pushes beyond known human capacities (like infrared vision), which raises genuinely different questions about altering the parameters of homo sapiens.

normativepending

Speaker

Alta Charo

Evidence Quote

“we do that all the time through other mechanisms. Whether it's nutrition or it's training. So it gets into another entire debate about meritocracy and earning things versus having them given to you”

Source

14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...