causal

Monetizing a Sacrifice Can Reduce Its Supply

Even if monetizing kidney donation is morally acceptable, paying for it may not increase supply, because socially acknowledging the gift as a heroic, noble, lovable sacrifice could motivate more donations, whereas paying for it converts the act into 'she just did it for money' and can produce the perverse effect of fewer donations by undermining the underlying norm.

causalpending

Speaker

Mary Hirschfeld

Evidence Quote

“maybe you get even more of it if you somehow socially acknowledge it as a heroic, noble, lovable sacrifice... you may actually have an adverse effect where you get fewer kidneys and not more.”

Source

Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:22 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...