factual

Speculative Reasons for Smith's Reticence

There is no certain answer for why Smith was so much more reticent than Hume on religion, but several non-mutually-exclusive explanations are plausible and likely partly true: temperamental circumspection, concern for reputation and career, viewing religion as less important or dangerous than Hume did, believing its dangers were better fought by quiet neglect than confrontation, a desire to avoid offending his pious Presbyterian mother with whom he lived most of his life, and learning a cautionary lesson from Hume's outspokenness.

factualpending

Speaker

Dennis Rasmussen

Evidence Quote

“maybe it's just a matter of temperament... Maybe he has more concern for his reputation, career, professional success... maybe it's just he saw what happened to Hume: He learned a lesson from Hume's relative outspokenness. And these, of course, aren't mutually exclusive.”

Source

Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...