The distinction between active (voluntary) ideas that we choose to have and passive (involuntary) ideas that come to us uninvited and unwanted provides the foundation for Berkeley's argument that passive ideas must have a cause external to our minds, and since they are mental phenomena they must be caused by another mind.
causalpending
Speaker
Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 45 Berkeley Replies to Objections [_P6nNM0aLWo]Evidence Quote
“there are some ideas that I have that I choose to have...on the other hand there are other ideas that are involuntary...so there must be some other cause than my mind for these involuntary or passive ideas”
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:42:56 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...