causal

Transformative choices violate act-state independence

Transformative choices break the assumption of act-state independence in decision theory: because making the choice itself changes who you are and what you prefer, you cannot assign value to the outcome ex ante and the question of whether the post-change self's satisfaction validates the choice becomes incoherent—the agent who is supposed to choose rationally for themselves is not the agent who ends up living with the choice.

causalpending

Speaker

L.A. Paul

Evidence Quote

“the agent is changed in virtue of making the choice. And so, then it's unclear first, what we can infer from the fact that down the line, the new agent is satisfied with the choice.”

Source

85 | L.A. Paul on Transformative Experiences and Your Future Selves— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...