causal

Collectivist rebuttal to the nonidentity problem

Parfit's nonidentity problem—that burying nuclear waste changes which people are born, so the future cancer victims weren't harmed because they wouldn't have existed otherwise—is answered by noting that not committing the harmful act yields a much greater aggregate of good in the distant future regardless of individual identities; this aggregate, oddly collectivist and slightly Hegelian, is what matters rather than person-affecting identities.

causalpending

Speaker

Tyler Cowen

Evidence Quote

“You might have different identities of people, but you’ll have a much greater aggregate of good in the more distant future. And it’s not about individual identities. So there’s something a little oddly collectivist about my argument, you might say.”

Source

Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:25:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...