normative

Judge Leaders Pragmatically, Not by Divine Claims

Because we cannot verify whether God spoke to a leader—we cannot 'cut windows into people's souls'—the way to judge the success of a leader, then and now, is pragmatically by results: David unified the kingdom, subdued rebellion, established Jerusalem as the capital, installed his son who built the temple, and left a lasting legacy.

normativepending

Speaker

Rabbi David Wolpe

Evidence Quote

“Since I can’t, as Queen Elizabeth said, “cut windows into people’s souls,” I have no idea if God spoke to David.”

Source

Rabbi David Wolpe— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...